This isn’t a partisan takedown. It’s a demand for results—from everyone in power.
I. SCARCITY IS A CHOICE
Donald Trump says we're out of everything—money, housing, energy, options. We can't afford immigrants, we can’t afford science, we can't afford to dream. He promises a "golden age" of America and then tells us to settle for less. Less healthcare. Less immigration. Less trust. Less future.
This isn't politics. It's sleight of hand. A shell game played by a billionaire who branded himself a victim of everyone less powerful than he is.
This isn’t just messaging—it’s machinery. The federal government is being reprogrammed in real time to shrink your future.
Trump doesn’t govern with a vision of greatness. He governs with a fear of loss. Loss of control. Loss of dominance. Loss of whatever empire he imagines he inherited. That’s why everything is a crisis. That’s why everything is an invasion. And that’s why he builds a wall, not a door.
His second-term policies—143 executive orders in the first 100 days alone—aren’t just reactionary. They’re rooted in a worldview that says America is out of room. Out of compassion. Out of breath. And if you want more? You must be taking it from someone else.
This is the politics of scarcity. It’s the idea that the only way to fix a broken system is to make it smaller, meaner, and harder to reach. It is, to borrow from economics, a zero-sum hellscape. And it's a lie.
We are not out of resources. We are out of courage. Courage to challenge broken institutions, yes—but also the courage to build new ones. That is the difference between power and leadership. Power hoards. Leadership expands.
And this—this right here—is where Democrats lose the plot.
II. IMMIGRATION: THE CRISIS THAT BOTH PARTIES BUILT
Let’s be honest: immigration policy in this country has been a bipartisan disaster. It’s the rare issue where both parties have been equally gutless, equally cynical, and equally responsible for a system that now functions as a humanitarian assembly line of cruelty, delay, and dysfunction.
Trump made it worse. That's not a partisan statement, it's a calendar. His second-term immigration agenda revived family separations, accelerated mass deportation raids, and gutted the already narrow pathways for asylum. In the name of “order,” he created chaos. In the name of “sovereignty,” he shattered due process. And in the name of “safety,” he made it more dangerous—on both sides of the border.
But Democrats don’t walk away clean. Because when they had both houses of Congress and the White House in 2021, they blinked. Faced with an historic opportunity to fix the immigration system, they squabbled, hesitated, and ultimately did... nothing. Nothing meaningful. Nothing lasting. Nothing courageous.
They ended some of Trump's most grotesque policies—thank God—but they also kept others. And in trying to strike a balance between compassion and political caution, they landed on paralysis. No vision. No reform. Just the status quo with nicer tweets.
Meanwhile, real people—families, workers, students, human beings—got lost in the gears. Caught between Republican punishment and Democratic paperwork. Neither side solved the problem. Both sides used it as a campaign ad.
This isn't governance. It’s performance art with a body count.
III. THE DEMOCRATIC CONTRADICTION
Here’s a question that makes Democrats sweat:
Why do blue states look so bad?
Seriously—why do places governed by the party of climate action, social equity, and human dignity so often feel... broken? The answer isn't ideology. It's execution.
Let’s talk about housing. Not just the crisis, but the farce.
California spends over $1.1 million per affordable housing unit. In San Francisco, a single public toilet project cost $1.7 million and took three years to approve—before they even poured the concrete. If that sounds like parody, congratulations, you’ve just described what millions of Americans think liberal governance looks like: bloated, tangled in red tape, and permanently stuck in the pre-construction phase of every good idea.
And clean energy? In theory, a Democratic crown jewel. In practice, blue states block renewable projects more often than red states. Offshore wind? Slowed by lawsuits. Solar farms? Choked in permitting. Transmission lines? Caught in a Kafkaesque web of environmental impact statements, zoning boards, and lawsuits from both NIMBYs and climate activists.
It's not corruption. It’s something worse: bureaucratic orthodoxy dressed in the robes of righteousness.
This is how Democrats lose elections they should win. They become the party of good intentions and garbage outcomes. They make it easier for conservatives to point to the dysfunction of governance and say, "See? Government is the problem."
And the problem isn’t that government is too big. The problem is it’s too slow, too timid, and too terrified of offending anyone on the journey to getting anything done.
This is the contradiction: the party that believes most in the power of government to help people has, in too many cases, made government synonymous with stagnation.
That has to change.
IV. THE CASE FOR ABUNDANCE
There is a better politics waiting to be written. One not based on fear of what we don’t have, but on belief in what we can build. A politics of abundance.
Not fantasy. Not false hope. Not free stuff.
Abundance means more of the things that actually make life better—more housing, more energy, more innovation, more medical breakthroughs, more dignity in the labor market, more courage in Congress, more risk-taking in science, and more competence in delivering the basics.
It means rejecting the idea that someone else’s gain is your loss. It means saying no to zero-sum thinking and yes to a 21st-century New Deal—not a handout, a rebuild.
This isn’t about left or right. It’s about forward. It’s about taking the best from every school of thought:
From progressives, the moral imperative to care for people who’ve been shut out.
From conservatives, the belief in national ambition and civic pride.
From libertarians, the hunger to demolish bureaucratic bottlenecks and cut the red tape that strangles new ideas.
And yes, that will make everyone uncomfortable. Good. That’s where the truth lives.
V. THE SCORCHED-EARTH STRATEGY
Donald Trump’s politics of scarcity isn’t passive—it’s aggressive. He didn’t just fail to build a better future. He dismantled the present.
Start with health care. Trump’s administration tried to repeal the Affordable Care Act more than 70 times. Not reform it. Not replace it. Just erase it. No backup plan, no framework, no serious alternative—just a vendetta in search of applause. That wasn’t governance. That was performance rage with a body count.
But let’s not pretend Democrats fixed it. After campaigning on lowering drug prices, expanding coverage, and even flirting with Medicare for All, they offered little more than tweaks. The ACA remains riddled with gaps. Millions remain uninsured or underinsured. And the most transformative ideas? They died in committee—again.
Housing? Same pattern. Trump slashed HUD funding, gutted fair housing rules, and made it easier for wealthy communities to block affordable development. But Democrats in blue cities and states didn’t exactly meet the moment. They passed progressive-sounding policies that took years to implement—if at all. Zoning reform stalled. Permitting dragged. Budgets ballooned. Meanwhile, working-class families got priced out and pushed aside.
And then there’s the climate. Trump pulled out of the Paris Agreement, rolled back over 100 environmental protections, and treated renewable energy like a personal insult. But while red states built oil pipelines at record speed, blue states buried clean energy projects in paperwork. Offshore wind farms, solar installations, transmission lines—all slowed by a maze of permitting rules, lawsuits, and “environmental” objections to actual environmental progress.
So yes—Trump lit the fire. But Democrats let it burn by being afraid to move fast, afraid to offend, afraid to break the very systems that are breaking us.
This is the real crisis: the party that tears it all down moves with ruthless speed. The party that claims to care can’t seem to find a shovel.
You don’t beat sabotage with symbolism. You beat it by building something people can see, touch, and live in. Something that works.
VI. THE VETOCRACY
We are living at the end of a political era. The neoliberal consensus that began with Reagan and matured under Clinton—that government should be small, markets should be free, and institutions should move slowly—has run its course.
And in its place, we’ve built something new and uniquely paralyzing: a vetocracy.
This is a system where no one can act because everyone can stop something. Where every good idea dies of a thousand cuts. Where climate projects are stopped by environmental lawsuits. Where housing is blocked by neighborhood councils. Where immigration reform is defeated by intra-party infighting. Where innovation chokes on process. Where vision dies in legal review.
Government is not just big—it’s inert. Not just inefficient—but engineered to be inefficient. Every agency, every court, every committee comes with a brake pedal, but no gas.
Where Every Idea Goes to Die
And the people notice. They see potholes that don't get fixed. They see a housing crisis no one can solve. They see pandemic funding stuck in administrative purgatory. And they draw the simplest—and most dangerous—conclusion: democracy doesn’t work.
This is how autocrats win. Not because they’re better. But because they promise speed. They promise decisiveness. They promise anything that feels like motion.
And if liberals can’t show what real, working, democratic governance looks like, people will take the counterfeit version.
VII. BUILD OR BE REPLACED
Here’s the uncomfortable truth: if Democrats don’t start building, they will be replaced by people who will. People like Donald Trump.
Not because he has the answers—he doesn’t. His vision is a cul-de-sac paved with fear. But because he sounds like he does. Because in the absence of a bold, functional, inclusive, and forward-looking alternative, people will choose the guy shouting into the void over the party whispering into its own hands.
It’s not enough to say what you’re against. It never was. You have to say what you’re for—and then you have to deliver.
Yes, Democrats passed the CHIPS Act. Yes, they passed the Inflation Reduction Act. Yes, they passed the largest infrastructure package in a generation. But they didn’t build a movement around those wins. They passed laws—then acted like the work was finished. Like policy without implementation could transform a country.
That means building housing. Not planning it. Not vision-boarding it. Building it.
It means approving wind farms and transmission lines in blue states with the same speed and force that red states build oil pipelines.
It means putting a shovel in the ground faster than you form another working group.
It means reforming the NIH to reward ambition, not bureaucracy.
It means fixing immigration like grown-ups—secure borders, legal pathways, humanity intact.
It means proving that the public sector is not a joke. That it can still work. That it can still win.
You can’t save democracy if you can’t pour a damn sidewalk.
The future will not be built by the loudest critic. It will be built by the most capable hands.
And right now, those hands are waiting for orders.
So, Democrats: stop reacting. Stop hand-wringing. Stop rehearsing your trauma and start rehearsing your vision. The country doesn’t need more press conferences. It needs progress. It doesn’t need more moral superiority. It needs moral competence.
We are not out of time. We are not out of ideas. We are only out of excuses.
And if Democrats don’t start building like they mean it—someone else will.
Imagine a visa approved, a wind turbine spinning, a cancer drug delivered—because somebody finally said yes.
So pick up the damn hammer. Or hand it to someone who will.
Great article! And could we also stop writing sternly worded letters because Bullies don’t care. Do things!
This is a wake-up call!
Is anybody listening?